By Rob Rhodes, Signal & Noise
Technology has always fascinated me. I've spent much of my life working with it, watching it evolve, and seeing how profoundly it changes the way we live. And for the most part, those changes have been extraordinary and beneficial.
But lately, with the pace of technological and societal change accelerating, are we becoming so focused on what technology makes possible that we're losing sight of what makes us human?
That's the main question I was pondering when I began to write Automatic Hearts.
I started writing the lyrics one Sunday afternoon this past June while sitting on my couch. As I explored the idea, the words came very quickly, and within an hour, I had the lyrics pretty much completed. A very different experience from writing Girl You're Gonna Take Home, as you'll know if you've already read the Behind the Song article for that one.
Together, but somewhere else
The opening verse describes a scene that's probably familiar to just about everyone.
Neon shadows light up the room
Blue light covers your face
The two of us together
But both in another place
Two people sitting together, physically close but emotionally and intellectually somewhere else. Their attention is captured by a screen rather than by each other.
Social media is a particularly good example of the contradiction I wanted to explore.
It's an amazing technological achievement if you think about it. We can maintain relationships across continents, reconnect with people we've lost touch with, discover communities that share our interests, and communicate on a scale that would have been difficult to imagine 25 years ago.
But there's another side.
The same technology that promises to bring us together also appears to pull us apart. We can spend hours following the lives of people we've never met while barely acknowledging the people sitting beside us. And the constant comparison, pursuit of approval, and pressure to remain connected can contribute to anxiety, loneliness, and other mental health challenges.
It's a strange contradiction. We've never had so many ways to connect, yet those connections don't necessarily make us feel closer to one another. In fact, in many ways, the very technology designed to connect us has been used to divide us.
And perhaps the strangest thing is how normal all of this has become.
That's the double-edged sword at the center of Automatic Hearts. Technological advancement can bring enormous benefits while also creating consequences that we may not fully appreciate until much later.
Loving fearlessly
One of my favorite images in the song is the reference to acrobats walking a high wire.
We used to love fearlessly
Like acrobats up high on a wire
I chose that image because love, like walking a tightrope, requires a certain amount of courage.
There's risk involved. You expose yourself to the possibility of being hurt. You have to trust someone else, sometimes without knowing whether that trust will be rewarded.
But isn't that vulnerability part of what makes love meaningful?
We're increasingly surrounded by technology designed to make our lives easier, safer, and more predictable. And while those things certainly have value, I wonder what happens when we start removing the uncertainty and emotional risk from our relationships.
That brings us to the chorus.
Automatic Hearts
Devoid of desire
To me, desire means much more than romantic attraction. It's the passion that makes us want to love, create, explore, discover, and experience life.
What happens if we become so good at automating our lives that we begin to lose those things?
One small step at a time
There's another idea in Automatic Hearts that I find particularly interesting, and it stems from another question that ran through my mind as I was writing.
Did mankind surrender its humanity
One small step at a time?
The reference to "one small step" is intentional.
When Neil Armstrong stepped onto the moon, it represented one of humanity's greatest technological accomplishments. We had achieved something almost unimaginable.
But I wanted to turn that idea around a little.
What if our greatest technological achievements also have consequences we don't fully recognize?
I don't believe humanity simply wakes up one morning and decides to surrender the things that make us human. It's more likely to happen gradually, through thousands of small choices that seem perfectly reasonable at the time. I felt that the phrase "one small step at a time" captured that idea to a T.
Each new convenience becomes part of everyday life. Each change seems insignificant compared with the last.
And eventually, we might find ourselves somewhere we never consciously intended to go.
That idea led me to the next verse.
Moving at light speed
We're moving at light speed
Not noticing the change
The man on the outside
Might think it's strange
This is another metaphor I particularly enjoyed writing.
The idea comes from Einstein's theory of special relativity and how time can be measured differently depending on whether you're the one moving or someone observing that motion from another frame of reference.
We're living inside an extraordinary period of technological acceleration. Because we're part of it, we adapt almost without thinking. Things that would have seemed unbelievable just a generation ago are now completely ordinary.
But imagine someone observing us from the outside.
Would they see progress? Would they see people becoming more connected and fulfilled?
Or would they wonder why we've willingly surrendered so much of our attention, independence, creativity, and human interaction — some of the very things that make us human and make life worth living?
Sometimes it's difficult to recognize how much something is changing when you're right in the middle of it.
More productive, but for what?
The tech makes us more productive
But I have to ask “for what?”
When every human touch is always undercut
This may be the question at the heart of the entire song.
We're constantly told that technology will make us more efficient and productive. And it does.
But productivity isn't necessarily the same thing as progress.
If we're able to accomplish twice as much but, in doing so, have left ourselves less time for the people we love, what have we gained?
If artificial intelligence can create, communicate, and make decisions for us, what happens to the satisfaction we get from doing those things ourselves?
I'm not suggesting we should reject these advances. Far from it. I'm genuinely excited about many of the possibilities.
But social media has already demonstrated that we don't always anticipate the consequences of the technologies we embrace. Something developed to connect people can ultimately change how they see themselves, how they interact with others, and even how they experience happiness.
As AI becomes increasingly integrated into our lives, I think it's worth remembering that lesson.
Technology should improve the human experience, not gradually replace it.
Can we change trajectory?
The bridge raises another question.
Did we all choose this?
Or just follow the crowd?
Are we moving too quickly?
To change trajectory now?
I deliberately used the word "trajectory" to continue some of the scientific imagery in the song.
A trajectory suggests that we're moving toward a destination, whether we've chosen it or not.
And that's what interests me.
Nobody individually decided what our relationship with technology should become. We made millions of little decisions, adopted new tools, embraced new conveniences, and gradually arrived where we are today — one small step at a time.
But are we actually steering?
And if we eventually decide we don't like where we're heading, will we still have the ability to change direction?
A question, not an answer
The song ends with a question.
Can we be happy
With automatic hearts
Devoid of desire?
I wanted to leave it there because I don't pretend to know the answer.
I'm not opposed to technology or artificial intelligence. Quite the opposite. I think we're entering an extraordinary period of discovery and possibility, and I'm genuinely excited about it.
But I also believe that some of the most important things in life can't be measured by efficiency or productivity.
Love, creativity, curiosity, passion, the excitement of discovery, and even the possibility of failure are all part of being human.
Maybe the challenge isn't figuring out how much technology can do for us.
Maybe it's deciding which parts of being human we never want it to replace.
And perhaps, every once in a while, we should look up from our screens and remember the person sitting beside us.
Listen to "Automatic Hearts" by Signal & Noise.
For more stories about the inspiration, writing, and production behind the music, visit signalandnoise.band.
Tune into the Signal.
Website / mailing list · Spotify · signalandnoiseband@gmail.com